Olivia Nuzzi’s memoir critiques political scandal but lacks depth

The Guardian
The Guardian
6m ago • 2 views
Olivia Nuzzi’s memoir American Canto explores her alleged affair with Robert F Kennedy Jr but avoids deeper analysis, blending political commentary with personal grievances and unresolved questions.
Olivia Nuzzi’s memoir critiques political scandal but lacks depth
A What happened
Olivia Nuzzi’s memoir American Canto, released in 2025, recounts her alleged affair with Robert F Kennedy Jr and its public fallout, while attempting to assert her seriousness as a writer and commentator. The book explores themes of misogyny, media bias, and political intrigue but often shifts away from the core incident, offering digressions on subjects like American history and philosophy. Nuzzi critiques how the affair was portrayed, highlighting the double standards she faced compared to Kennedy Jr, yet she refrains from a deep self-reflective analysis of her own conduct. Critics suggest the memoir contains potential but is hindered by over-intellectualization and filler, and that it misses opportunities to provide substantive insights into the political and personal dimensions of the scandal. The memoir also touches on Nuzzi’s interactions with powerful figures, but the narrative remains focused on her desire to be recognized seriously rather than offering thorough revelations.

Key insights

  • 1

    Memoir addresses media and gender bias

    Nuzzi discusses the sexist public reactions she faced as a young female journalist amid an alleged affair with a prominent politician.

  • 2

    Avoidance of in-depth self-reflection

    The book skirts a critical appraisal of Nuzzi’s own role or behavior in the alleged affair, focusing more on victimization and external narratives.

  • 3

    Mix of political analysis and personal narrative

    American Canto combines reflections on American politics with personal anecdotes but often diverges into tangential topics rather than focusing on the scandal’s core issues.

Takeaways

While American Canto offers perspectives on sexism and media narratives in political scandals, it falls short of providing a comprehensive or critically insightful account of Olivia Nuzzi’s alleged affair with Robert F Kennedy Jr.

Topics

Culture & Society Media