Government claim that lawmakers cannot discuss ECI is violation of powers of Parliament: Derek O'Brien

The Hindu
The Hindu
2M ago
Derek O'Brien claims the government's ban on discussing the Election Commission in Parliament violates parliamentary powers. He demands a discussion in the upcoming Winter session.
Government claim that lawmakers cannot discuss ECI is violation of powers of Parliament: Derek O'Brien
A What happened
Derek O'Brien, a leader of the Trinamool Congress, has asserted that the government's claim preventing lawmakers from discussing the Election Commission of India (ECI) is a violation of parliamentary powers. He highlighted that the ECI's budget is subject to parliamentary approval, thus granting MPs the authority to scrutinize the commission. O'Brien pointed out that various opposition parties have submitted over 100 notices demanding a discussion on electoral transparency. He criticized the Modi government for avoiding this topic, suggesting that it is essential for the government to engage in open discussions about the ECI. O'Brien referenced past instances where the ECI was discussed in Parliament, arguing that the government's refusal to allow such discussions is unfounded. He plans to renew calls for a debate on the ECI in the upcoming Winter session.

Key insights

  • 1

    Parliamentary Power: O'Brien argues that MPs have the right to discuss the ECI due to budget approval authority.

  • 2

    Opposition Unity: Multiple opposition parties are united in demanding transparency in the electoral process.

  • 3

    Historical Precedent: Past discussions on the ECI in Parliament contradict the government's current stance.

Takeaways

The ongoing debate over the Election Commission's role highlights tensions between the government and opposition regarding electoral transparency and parliamentary authority.

Topics

World & Politics Elections Policy & Regulation

Stay ahead with OwlBrief

Daily briefs that distill the world’s important events — clear, verified, and designed for understanding.

Newsletter

Get OwlBrief in your inbox

A fast, high-signal digest of the day’s most important events — plus the context that makes them make sense.

Quick to read. Useful all day.